Comments:
I bought the Liquid Logic Pisgah and the similarly priced Wilderness Systems, for my Old Town Cayuga 160. Both fit the hatch just fine. But the Pisgah's bungee cord (which seals around the hatch) sits in a too-wide channel, which makes it hard to strap it into place. The Wilderness Systems is easier to attach, plus has suspenders. So I returned the Pisgah and kept the WS.