Average Rating:
Sort by:
decent technology, questionable finish
By chris from missouri on 6/18/2008
Sizing:
Feels full size too big
Width:
Feels true to width
Cons:
Cheap nondurable graphic
Best Uses:
Climbing, Long-distance riding, Sprinting
Describe Yourself:
Competitive Cyclist
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
its basically a somewhat cheap upper tied to a relatively nice carbon sole. So, basically for those who are seeking a carbon soled shoe on the cheap. Its not a BAD shoe per se, but Northwave sizing is funky relative to euro standards... 9.5 is 42.5 in northwave, but 43.5 everywhere else.
Graphics are insanely cheap. Its like a very thin graphic that doesnt adhere to the leather very well. So, Ive ordered TWO of these shoes and sent them both back because there were graphics rubbed off the shoe and the BOX HAD NEVER BEEN OPENED. So... if looks aren't everything and you are looking for a basic shoe... then this may be for you. I would get an aftermarket insert or use orthotics because the footbed molding is almost nonexistent, and somewhat flat.
Nice technology, poor graphics
By funknuggets from Kansas City Area on 6/16/2008
Sizing:
Feels full size too big
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Carbon Sole, Durable Sole, Stiff sole
Best Uses:
Everyday riding, Long-distance riding, Sprinting
Describe Yourself:
Competitive Cyclist
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Comments: Fair enough shoe, and decent technology... alas without a ratchet-type closure... as well as very cheap graphics that WILL RUB off regardless of how easy you are on the shoe. Ive ordered two pairs of these, both came OUT OF THE PACKAGE with graphics rubbed off, and one looked as though someone had tried to cover up the rubbed off graphics with some kind of white paint marker. So... basically its a very standard three strap upper slapped on a pretty nice carbon sole. No more no less. These things seem to run big in euro... so if you have 9.5 feet, you would typically get a 43.5 or so in euro... not with Northwaves. Go a full size down to 42.5.
By Ian from AK on 5/26/2008
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Pros:
Durable Sole, Simple to Use, Well Ventilated
Best Uses:
Climbing, Everyday riding, Long-distance riding, Sprinting
Describe Yourself:
Competitive Cyclist
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Comments: Simple, and high quality.
By for fun from chatt tn on 5/8/2008
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Durable Sole, Simple to Use, Well Ventilated
Cons:
All velcro no ratchets
Best Uses:
Everyday riding
Describe Yourself:
Avid Cyclist
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Comments: I like these shoes alot. Fit good, feel comfortable, and cost almost nothing compaired to same in quality other brands. I am woried about the velcro wearing out before the rest of the shoe though. Wish they had ratchets.
By Cryin' Ryan from Western New York State on 4/21/2008
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Durable Sole, Simple to Use, Well Ventilated
Best Uses:
Commuter shoes, Long-distance riding, Sprinting
Describe Yourself:
Casual/ Recreational
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Comments: This is my first pair of road shoes so I don't have anything to compare them to but so far so good. I've probably on put about 7 miles on them (pathetic, I know) but so far so good. Hopefully they'll stay great as I break them in. I haven't really noticed them on my feet so I suppose that's a good thing!
Non-mesh version of the Aerator
By Chris from Sierras on 1/20/2008
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Width:
Feels true to width
Describe Yourself:
Competitive Cyclist
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Comments: These Revenge shoes are a simpler (lighter?) version of the fantastic Aerator which is now in its fourth generation, known as the "AeroLite". Now, these Revenge shoes are made with the same top quality fit and materials, but without the titanium mesh cages that are great for very hot weather, and optional for normal weather. I can see using the black on cooler days and 2 pair (1 of each) would last many seasons, no matter how hardcore you are. I have used the Aerators for about 15000 miles and they are just now starting to look "not quite new". I have used them in extreme tempuratures. These shoes are the first to allow me to "set and forget" the strap tension. I used Sidi from 1991 to 2001 (6 pairs of Genius 3 through 4, plus a pair of Tecnos and a pair of Energy. The Sidi Genius 4 and later suck, because the arch-compression is now 2-piece and pinches a nerve when tightened for competition (unless you are very light, I weigh 170). As soon as I saw the long awaited model with Carbon Fiber sole (the "Ergo 1") and that is was not only remaining with the crumbpy (still current) arch-compression system, but the sole was not even carbon biber around the edges. Making it cheaper was supposed to be a benefit, until they change is and then the NEW sole is better than all of the other brands because THEY are not not as "pure" carbon fiber soles. It makes me sick to see and hear the hype, because these past 2 decades have been fantastic for cycling technology in so many ways. But literally every single product claims to be furthering that trend and that is just not true. REgarding shoes again, Sidi offers full custom shoes to the pros who wear them, so it was no surprise when the Sidi Genius turned cheap and crumbpy. The first 3 models (through the Genius 3, until the "Millenium" sole, which was claimed as an upgrade, but at the same time the reduced the material on the original Sidi Genius arch-compression, which combined with the ratchet, made it truly Genius at the time. When I saw the Ergo crumb shoes, I remembered that DMT had an ad for the new Ultimax Carbon Fiber shoes (as used by Jalabert and others). This shoe was not only an early adoptor of great CF soles, but they also used an arch compression system nearly identical the the original Genius, plus they had fully integrated heel cup as well. In fact, the higher visibility Nike "Lance" shoes from 2000 onward to today are all built on DMT models, Ultimax through the latest shoe based on the DMT "Flash". So, I was thrilled with my DMTs, had 2 pair, but I was not happy that the Ultimax was replaced (for 2 seasons though now it is back) with 2 pairs of new shoes that were really nice, but no mesh sections. THis is why a thrilled DMT user (and the pickiest guy EVER in cycling, but seriously I have a very severe injury on my right ankle) and I needed to make sure I would have at least one pair of shoes as good or better than my Ultimax shoes, and with at least as much cooling. The white pair used in hot weather wore out quicker then the sikver /blue pair and I started trying on alternatives. I kid you not, the Northwave Aerators and all others from 2004 onward (all the same last, which dictates the fit of all shoes made this way) are the only shoes every to feel fantastic from the time I tried them on and even during the "shakedown" rides. It is said that synthetic materials do not stretch and thus do not require break-in. This is BS because your feet or whatever body part we are talking about needs to adapt to the new pressure points. This is why when you find some shoes that treat you right, buy as many pair as you can afford and think you can use. It could be that a combination of using a similar last, and also the fact that my foot is very close to the shape the last is optimized for, but I never once had any discomfort. The mesh also allows me to stay much cooler in the 100+ degree summer days in the Sierras. They have the Aerator Race (using the now ubiquitous ratchet instead of the top velcro strap) and the Northwave Ratchet is also the besst available. In fact, it is the only strap of this style that does not ratchet, but uses a threaded system. Sidi invented it, and then devised a system that double the resolution, adding half-steps to the ratchet. Then Morthwave designs a strap with infinite adjustment! Literally perfect amount of tension with Zero stretch or possible misadjustment (velcro is not too bad, but you can't beat the NW systems. I was absolutely convinced that DMT were the very best. ANd they were, I just could not imagine Northwave being clearly even better!
|