“Not great - not bad”

“I ordered 2 of these as gifts - one came in the wrong color, and I wasn't impressed with either color when I saw them 'in person'. I'm sending them back, mainly because: 1) They seem to run kind of small (narrow) so I'm nervous about giving them as gifts 2) They're from a high-quality retailer, but on these the stitching around the button placket isn't very well done, and isn't particularly attractive. The stitching makes them look much more 'casual' than I had expected. They are a good buy for the price though. If you want something for hiking or just hanging around, these would work well. They are cut rather narrow, but they're rib knit, so they do have 'give' to them. Go up a size if you're wondering at all...”