Customer Reviews Of:
Frye Otis Penny Loafer Shoes (For Women)

Closeouts. Frye's Otis penny loafer shoes are a comfortable, casual interpretation of the classic penny loafer, crafted in supple, pebbled leather with stacked heel and leather sole.

Average Rating based on 4 reviews 4.000000 0 5
  • Sort by:
  • Reviewed by Debi from Northern Virginia on Tuesday, December 10, 2013
    well made, inside is so soft tot he touch. I am glad I bought them, they look nice with straight leg jeans.
  • Reviewed by Lap Swimmer from Ann Arbor, Michigan on Wednesday, October 30, 2013
    I love opening a box and seeing a really high-quality pair of shoes in it. These Frye penny loafers did not disappoint until I put them on. Darn it, they were too big in length. Sometimes I wear a 9.5, mostly a 10, but this Frye 10 was WAY too long and even a thick pair of socks wasn't going to fix it. Had to return them...no 9.5 available, just a 9.
  • Reviewed by MountainView from Boston, MA on Friday, June 14, 2013
    Well made, to Frye's usual standards. I usually wear a 9 in Frye boots, and the 9 in this loafer works well with thin socks (though too tight with thick socks); if I were to order a 9.5, however, I think it would be much too loose in the heel. I ordered the brown color, which is really blah, and might have preferred them in the black. Nothing special, however, in terms of looks, but if you're looking for a plain, well-constructed loafer, this might fit the bill.
  • Reviewed by Colorado gal from Colorado on Tuesday, May 21, 2013
    This are the best rendition of the old penny loafer that I have seen in a long time! I bought these in black - they are incredibly comfortable and have just the right amount of "geek" factor with a pair of black jeans. Only a minor problem, the "penny" component is not stitched down, so you can't really slip a penny into the pocket, but a minor detail and otherwise great! I usually wear a size 5-6, and Fryes always fit perfect for me in a size 5.5! Love!!
  • Sort by: