Hart

Absolutely wonderful. It'll be perfect for what I need!

good in cold weather

Not bad. I am not a turtleneck expert, but so far I like it.

should be 2or 3 inches longer

[...] but the neck part of this turtlenect stretches out and looks sloppy and does not retain a tight snug fit around the neck, cheap price and cheaply made!

due to length, i wear this under another garment

Way too short in body, could never wear this as you couldn't even tuck it in.

Lightweight - came out of the first-time wash - dry bit GREAT. I'm tough to fit in the long-arms area, but this one is fine. Have a bit of a prob with the length from neck to waist - just a little bit too short. Needed a white turtle to go under heavier outer shirts, and this fits the bill. No ribbed hem, so too loose to wear untucked methinks; if it's tucked in and worn solo, it's def going to creep on out of the jeans. Still, for the price I got (under 11...SHIPPED), this was a sweet find.

Neck size is way too big. Body length is short, even in "tall" size.

Would be an acceptable shirt but forget about listing it as tall, it is for average size people.