“Not entirely sure”

“Not sure what to rate these since my use for these was unique. I bought these to keep my hands warm during a long distance mud/obstacle run. I first purchased size large, since that is what size glove I always purchase. It was too loose so I exchanged for a medium. The size was better but the wrist was still too loose and allowed too much water into the glove. I didn't have time to try a size small but since they are neoprene and stretch that size might have been the right size. These kept my hands warm when wet (and running) but were "heavy" since they filled with water when I ran through the water - I found myself squeezing them a lot to extract the water. I couldn't use them for obstacles, like monkey bars or climbing rope, since the neoprene would just twist in my hands. I ended up using synthetic contractor gloves and although not as warm these worked much better on the obstacles. I think these would be OK for wet fishing conditions but not for my uses. Even for fishing, they are a thicker neoprene and you won't be able to do much with them on (unlike the ones with the retractable fingers). Due to the cost I think these are worth a try, depending on your needs.”