“okay but not great”

“I bought one of these for myself (blue) and one for my mother-in-law (black). The blue one is relatively attractive; the black one is not (all of the little holes just look weird to me). I wanted to exchange the black one for her but she was fine with it. Is a decent weight for layering, but I found the fit to run large. I got a S but it hangs quite loosely on me and would be hard to wear under something else unless that something else was pretty oversized. It's okay, but I won't be getting as much wear out of it as I had hoped. Will keep but wouldn't reorder.”