By bcskier
from Pacific Northwest on 05/11/2010
Best Uses:
Alpine, Telemarking
Describe Yourself:
On The Mountain
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Cliffs Notes:
The Carbon Pro used to be an awesome, durable pole, but now it's cheaply made -- mine broke before I even skied with them.
All the Details:
I bought a pair of Carbon Pro poles back in the mid-1990s and took them on hundreds of backcountry tours and dozens of in-area days before losing them a year or so ago. STP had a great deal on some closeouts (not seconds), I loved the first set, so I bought another.
Compared to my original pair, the fit and finish on the new ones is poor: inconsistent coating at the base of shaft, they are not the same length when fully collapsed, the textured grip area is not as grippy, and one of the adjustment mechanisms was stiff. In fact, I sent them back for a replacement due to the stiffness, but the second set had the same problem, so I resolved to fix it myself.
I used to spray silicone in the metal shafts of my old poles to keep the adjusters working well -- this was a fine solution to their occasional sticking. When I sprayed the new poles, however, the silicone dissolved the glue holding the black/gray end caps in place: the poles came apart in my hands. So Life-Link is using a different kind of glue than on my old poles.
(A similar failure happened to a friend on a trip recently: one of his poles came apart when he extended it because the end cap popped out, only he'd never lubricated his with silicone. Note that the adjuster pieces are clear plastic -- NOT easy to find when they fall on the snow!!)
Aluminum oxidizes, and in the 12+ years with my original pair, I found that the adjusters *will* eventually stick because of this. So now I have to find a glue that is non-permanent (in case the internal adjuster mechanisms, which are plastic, break) *and* is resistant to silicone in order to use the poles as they were designed.
If these poles don't last, it will be a no-brainer to opt for a set from Black Diamond next time. Meanwhile, it's a shame that Life-Link's quality has slid so dramatically.