Reviewed by SmittyNYUSA from NY on Wednesday, July 15, 2015
I wear a LARGE in every jacket i have bought/own, and I own a LOT of high end jackets for skiing.
This LARGE just fit in the arm length and torso, but the ARMPITS were way too tight.
If I tried to wear a thick fleece under it, it was way too small. I wear a fleece and even a vest also under all my other jackets (Marker, 2 Marmot, LLBean, etc.) and they all fit fine in a large. I am 5'10" and 180 lbs.
The build is also flimsy, I guess it's OK for a rain jacket but for this price I expected more. They claim it's TRIPLE layer, I can only find ONE LAYER!
Reviewed by HoJo from Denver, CO on Wednesday, December 31, 2014
I've owned lots of MH products over the years and I've always been an XL. This jacket was way to small in the shoulders and sleeve length. I returned it with no hassles. Too bad, the sale price was good but the quality would have been poor for the full retail price.
Reviewed by JBski603 from New Hampshire on Sunday, December 21, 2014
Great jacket, both warm and dry, always a plus. I have big shoulders and had to return my large for an extra large, so if you have broad shoulders go one size up or you won't be able to lift your arms above your head. Happy skiing!!
Reviewed by Auburngrad from Southeast Tennessee on Wednesday, June 4, 2014
I got this jacket to replace my old Marmot Stretch Armstrong, that was around 12 or 13 years old. I hope I can get that kind of life out of this jacket. It seems very well made, and MH is a great brand that will stand behind their products. I love the fit of this jacket, as it does not carry to much extra bulk. I could wear one of my more fitted windstopper fleeces, or a vest under it, and would stay warm and dry in the colder months. I actually picked up the MH Trinity also, so that I would have a warmer soft shell for winter, and the hard shell for the other 3 seasons. I do plan on wearing it during the winter on exceptionally wet days.
I found the sizing to work well, especially being a warmer season, and hard shell. I ordered a large, and haven't thought about uping to an XL. I like the trimmer fit, as there is not fabric flapping about. Now, I do understand the reviews, as I never use to buy MH, as it was always a larger fit. This is closer to what Marmot and Arcteryx were known for in slimmer fit. I feel my vest and newer fleeces with trim fits will fit this. The sleeves are long enough, and shoulders work through the range of motions. I think the pockets are fine with packs, and with Mountain Smith Lumbar packs. I am 6'3", and 185 pounds, and shirt size is 17" with 35" sleeves.
Ask away if there are any specific questions you have.
Reviewed by Firek from Maryland on Tuesday, March 25, 2014
I'm 6' 160 lbs and mostly torso: I need a large pack to get the right distance between hips and shoulders. I ordered a medium size. The overall length is just right for a jacket (this is not a parka). The jacket ends 1-2" above my groin. The sleeve length is perfect, not too short at all. Usually those are my two main issues with medium jackets.
The overall fit is trim, which is what I was looking for. I'm a fairly trim person, 38-40 size jackets with a 30 inch waist. In dress shirts I wear a slim or extra slim 15-34. This won't be bunching up under a hip belt or my harness. It fits very well over medium weight layers (base + windstopper fleece) with one caveat: those need to fit well too. I tried it on over an old and loved "too large" camp fleece and it was "ok" but definitely bunched up the fleece in the spots where it was too big. This was most noticeable in the underarms where the pit-zips are. It was also noticeable in the chest/stomach area where my large fleece bunched up as well.
With my arms raised, the jacket rises a little, but never over my belt line. The only time I was able to expose skin was touching my toes, where the back of the jacket rose just above my belt line.
Bottom line: the sizing info on the MH website is spot on for this jacket in a medium (39-41 chest, 34 sleeve). If you've got a boxy build or a bit of a belly, consider sizing up.