Reviewed by Gloria from San Bernardino, CA on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
Purchased this for my son in a size S because most Carhartt shirts and sweatshirts I have purchased in the past seem to be rather generously sized, and he prefers a trim fit. Excellent quality as one would expect from Carhartt, well made, heavy fabric, warm--but ended up being WAAAY too small...this has never happened to me before and I have ordered many items in this brand. Maybe this is actually a mislabeled boy's or women's sweatshirt, or perhaps mis-sizing was the reason this was classified as a second? There is certainly nothing else wrong with it, and it ended up fitting my very petite daugher (110#, women's size XS or S, so no way this sweatshirt is a men's S) and it looks great & will keep her warm and toasty. This is definitely a 5-star product, but I knocked one off for the sizing issue (maybe I should have knocked off two); admittedly I would not have been very happy if I had ended up having to return this item, so I can only recommend buying it if the purchaser doesn't mind returning/exchanging an incorrectly sized garment.