Stillwater Supply Co . Oilskin Shirt Jacket (For Men)

I am glad I bought it.

price was good, shipping was fast, shirt arrived well packaged.
unfortunately, when I opened the bag, it smelled like someone had broken a bottle of cologne/perfume/room spray in with the shirt. the smell was so strong, it gave me and the wife headaches and the dogs asked to be let outside. I sent an email to customer service that was never answered, but a week and a half later I received 2 requests from them for feedback and customer service surveys.
so first things first - detailed visual inspection of the shirt -- lightweight fabric, not greasy feeling, seams are good - no loose threads, see-through snaps are snug, but not nail-breakers, lines sleeves and on-seam pockets. The used lighter in the right pocket works nice -- thanks for the bonus! flannel lining probably in the 4 oz range, and it has a vintage/distressed look -- edges of the sleeves and collar are a slightly different color as though the oil treatment was worn, etc.....
by that time, my eyes were watering, so I read the laundry instructions and tossed it in the washing machine with some bath towels on cold cycle, then hung it to dry over a floor vent overnight - cut the smell in half, had to rewash the towels to get the smell out of them, and it still gave the wife headaches when i wore it into town...
2 days after getting it, I wore it to a friends and stood in the smoke while he built a fire for his kids to make s'mores. whatever the first owner doused it with is effective, because it didn't smell like smoke after that.
10 days later it still smells, but much fainter, no longer makes my eyes water, chases the dogs out of the house, or gives the wife headaches.

now for the part some of you really want to hear -- the reason it gets 3 stars despite all that, the shirt itself, sans odors, is excellent. wind does not go through it. the flannel lining is just enough that I'm comfortable in it at 20f - but not baking myself to death at 55f (it's February, we haven't had any days above that yet). I have not encountered any rain, snow, or sleet yet, so I do not know how well it will fend off water.

overall, had this been advertised as open box/returned item, it would have gotten 5 stars -- it does exactly what I wanted, it provides me with a lightweight outer layer that will get me through 3 seasons.

Like it a lot. Seems to run large