Didn't fit, so Rating is subjective
Verified Buyer Reviewed by Dan the Trout lover from Kansas City on Friday, December 26, 2014
This jacket seemed to be just what I was looking for: a good volume of sheet synthetic insulation, with a waterproof shell. But, 2 problems with that: 1) the jacket was way too big, and STP doesn't have a small, and 2) the insulation seemed way too thin to provide the warmth I expected. I could only guess about that, because I could wear the jacket. Returned the same day. Sorry.