Verified Buyer Reviewed by Spark from Iowa on Sunday, January 31, 2016
I would probably give these boots an extra half star. They are extremely comfortable. The zipper/lace combination allows you to customize the fit. They do run slightly small and the 44 fit very well for my usual size 10 wide. Zippers are slightly stubborn where boot flexes and need to be closed before you tighten the laces. After a mild week in Yellowstone(low of 3 degrees F), they were waterproof and had decent insulation. At colder temperatures it might depend on activity levels and how good your circulation is.